Thursday, September 27, 2007

A Christian and a Democrat

“I can’t vote for a Democrat,” a man once told me. “I’m a Christian.” He spoke these two labels as if they were a set of antonyms. He could not grasp my attempts to explain that one label referred to a religion while the other referred to a political party. Some preacher had told him that all Christians are Republicans, and he had accepted this factoid without thinking.

I tried another approach. “Do you know how the Democratic Party meetings are opened?” I asked.

He raised one eyebrow warily, as if he expected to hear that we sacrificed infants or pledged our souls to the devil.

“We open with prayer,” I told him. “Then we say the Pledge of Allegiance.”

He stood there for a moment, dazed. “Including the ‘under God’ part?”

“That part, too,” I answered, and watched as he walked away, wheels turning in his head.

The Republican Party claims to be God’s party, even while they oppress the fatherless, the foreigner and the poor – the very people God warned us not to oppress. (Zech 7:10.)

Rev. Jim Nelson, who will be speaking at the Catoosa County Democratic Rally & Barbecue at Lakeview-Fort Oglethorpe High School Saturday night, puts it like this, “I am not a Democrat in spite of being a Christian. I am a Democrat because I am a Christian.”

As for the current crop of Republicans, there is hardly a moral conservative among them. It seems another GOP member comes out of the closet (or the airport restroom stall) every week. These days we’re just happy if we can keep them off the under-age congressional pages.

A bizarre conversion is sweeping the Republican Party, though. Mitt Romney, who pandered to the gay and lesbian community in 1994, has become their biggest opponent. Rudy Giuliani, who worked to increase gun control as mayor of New York City, has suddenly become a believer in the 2nd Amendment and a fan of the NRA. Meanwhile, Episcopalian candidate John McCain has suddenly realized that he is a Baptist – and has been for many years even as his campaign materials called him an Episcopalian. What’s next? Will Mitt Romney reveal that he is actually a black woman? No, that might conflict with his Latter Day Saints Bible, which calls black skin a curse.

If Baptist is what the voters want, then McCain will retroactively become a Baptist. It’s hard to say whether that will help him, as there have been more Episcopalians than Baptists in the White House. In fact, Baptist presidents have typically been judged harshly by those affiliated with the Baptist church.

The first Baptist president was Warren G. Harding. Harding, a Republican, is often listed among a handful of “worst presidents” in terms of lackluster leadership and widespread corruption. The other three Baptist presidents were all Democrats: Harry Truman, Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton.

Let’s talk about Jimmy Carter. As President, Carter orchestrated peace between Egypt and Israel, and talked the Soviet Union through the SALT II treaty to reduce nuclear arms. He advanced equal opportunity for women and minorities. He created the Department of Education and the Department of Energy to make sure that every American had access to quality education and reliable electricity – things we now take for granted. Carter introduced the concept of environmental protection legislation. After leaving office, Carter participated in numerous projects and foundations to help people all around the world. Habitat for Humanity is probably the most widely known. In 2002, Jimmy Carter won the Nobel Peace Prize for his continued diplomatic work around the world. Yet most Baptists hate him.

Carter always showed himself to be a statesman, a faithful husband, and a strong Christian. He was never caught using lewd words when he did not realize the microphone was on, like Bush. Carter has published numerous devotional books which you can borrow from our county library. Since age 18, he has taught Sunday school at a Baptist church. Even while in Washington, he taught a Sunday school class there. Do you think our current president even attends church on Sunday? Hint: No.

It’s not that Bush’s pew is empty. He doesn’t have one. The man who claims God speaks to him directly, has no church at all. And don’t tell me the free leader of the world can’t find time to go to church. If he can find time to spend a third of his presidency on vacation, he can find time to go to the House of God.

Reagan did not bother with church either, even though he was often called the nation’s “pastor.” Reagan’s excuse for being unchurched was that the security detail required to protect him would be a burden, causing parishioners to leave. The Clintons, who were active members of Foundry United Methodist Church during Bill Clinton’s term in the White House, had no problem attending.

According to his biographers, Carter may be the most personally devout president America ever had. Yet Baptist leaders inexplicably loathe Carter. Many preachers have called him godless, denying that he was ever a Christian.

Meanwhile, these same people support President Bush as God’s man of the hour, even though he has rarely darkens the door of a church, supports killing and torture rather than working for peace, has demonstrated no knowledge of Scripture, and would have trouble coming up with a bedtime prayer without help from Karl Rove.

The fact is, Baptist leaders don’t support Baptists. Baptist leaders support Republicans. You will even see them support a Mormon, if Mitt Romney wins the Republican nomination. Mitt Romney has already spoken at Pat Robertson’s Regent University’s commencement– even though Robertson’s website lists Mormons as a cult for denying salvation through faith in Christ. Maybe faith in Christ is less important to Robertson than imagining himself a kingmaker.

Republicans often charge that Democrats are immoral. They forget that the moral values held by most Americans include compassion, honesty, integrity, and respect for all people. Let’s consider how our current president stacks up on these values.

Compassion: Bush cut Head Start and school lunch programs, and has now promised to cut health care to millions of children all over the country.

Honesty: Bush lied about WMD’s in Iraq and repeatedly insinuated that Saddam Hussein was behind the 9/11 attacks.

Integrity: Bush sought to prevent both the independent investigation and the congressional investigation of the 9/11 attacks.

Respect for all people: Would that include the thousands of American soldiers and the hundreds of thousands of Iraqi men, women and children slaughtered in a war founded on lies?

My Christian faith does not allow me to vote for more lies, war, sickness and poverty.

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

An open letter to Christian pastors

Pastors, have you ever preached a sermon against domestic violence? Odds are, you haven’t. I’ve listened to approximately 4,000 sermons and have yet to hear a pastor condemn domestic violence from the pulpit.

Southern preachers prefer to pontificate on matters like abortion and homosexuality. Sometimes they rail against feminism. On occasion they preach against pornography, using the occasion to slam churchwomen over immodest attire. In every denomination, pastors preach often enough on tithing, and never fail to pass the plate. Yet they fail at addressing an issue faced by approximately one fourth of their congregation.

Recently a wildly popular pastor shoved the problem of Christian violence into the spotlight when he choked, kicked and stomped his wife in the parking lot of an Atlanta hotel. In the South, beating your wife may or may not be a crime. Records show that the most common law enforcement response to domestic violence is “separating the parties.” Victims rarely press charges because they fear reprisal. Law enforcement rarely presses their own charges (though they could and should), essentially treating wife-beating as a “victimless crime.”

Bishop Thomas W. Weeks, III crossed the line that even Georgia will not tolerate: He was wearing shoes when he kicked his wife. That’s a felony. Besides that, he committed the acts publicly and on video surveillance tape. He also threatened to kill her, which is another Georgia felony.

The abused wife, Prophetess Juanita Bynum, is an internationally acclaimed televangelist and best-selling author who empowers Christian women with her preaching. Church members say that couple of weeks before the attack, Weeks announced that Bynum would no longer be preaching at the church they founded.

Bynum is pressing charges against Weeks and seeking to end the marriage. Attorneys for Weeks say he will contest the divorce on the grounds that she was cruel. The strangest part of this story is not that the man who kicked and stomped his wife is contesting the divorce or fighting the charges; that happens all the time. What is so bizarre is where this man was just a few days after the beating: He was behind his pulpit telling his congregation that the devil made him do it.

Finally, a preacher is talking about domestic violence! If only his congregation had responded with a resounding movement down the aisle – and right out the church door. No one should sit under the teaching of a wife-beater. The elders should have stripped this man of his title and never let him behind the pulpit again.

T. D. Jakes, the famous televangelist who helped bring Bynum to power, condemned violence against women in a written statement two weeks after the attack. He pointed out that every day, four American men murder their wives or girlfriends, resulting in 1,400 deaths per year. That’s an FBI statistic. He also mentioned that over half a million cases of intimate assault are reported each year. Most cases go unreported. According to the most conservative estimates, between 2,000,000 and 4,000,000 women are battered each year. In 1990, the U.S. had 3,800 shelters for animals, and only 1,500 shelters for battered women.

Other Christian leaders even try to blame the victims. Christian author Gillis Triplett claims that there are thirteen traits common to abused wives, including “THEY LOVE THE DRAMA!” (Emphasis his.) Evangelical leaders John MacArthur and James Dobson have both gone on record stating that women must be careful not to “provoke” abuse. In the 1996 printing of “Love Must Be Tough,” Dobson told a story about a woman who was physically beaten by her husband. Dobson concluded that the woman “baited” her husband to hit her so that she could show off her black eye, which he calls her “prize.”

Following the advice and example of such leaders, thousands of pastors regularly dismiss domestic violence and send women back into dangerous situations. With “saving the marriage” as the highest aim, these pastors seek to prevent divorce at all costs. Women receive the subtle message that their pain – or even their lives -- are not as important as keeping the marriage intact.

One woman told a victims’ support group how she took her children and fled the state in fear of her life. Her church responded by sending her a letter of ex-communication.

In the introduction to her new book "Woman Submit! Christians & Domestic Violence,” Jocylen Andersen states that "The practice of hiding, ignoring, and even perpetuating the emotional and physical abuse of women is ... rampant within evangelical Christian fellowships and as slow as our legal systems have been in dealing with violence against women by their husbands, the church has been even slower." The Christian wife abuse cover-up is every bit as evil as the Catholic sex abuse cover-up.

Christian leaders set the stage for domestic violence by perpetuating pop-culture stereotypes of femininity and masculinity. T. D. Jakes claims in his book “Woman, Thou Art Loosed” that all women were created to fulfill the vision of some man. Jakes bases his gender theology solely on the physical characteristics of male and female genitalia, insisting that all women are “receivers” and all men are “givers.” This false dichotomy breaks down quickly when one considers that female sexuality includes giving birth and giving milk. More importantly, Jakes deviates from Scripture in claiming that women and men must operate like their genitalia in every facet of life.
John MacArthur also does his part to set the stage for female subjugation. He calls the women’s movement “Satanic.” In a sermon called “God’s Design for a Successful Marriage: The Role of the Wife” MacArthur blames working women for everything from smog to prison overcrowding. As an antidote, he offers this quote from Charles Haddon Spurgeon on the disposition of a godly wife toward her husband: “He is her little world, her paradise, her choice treasure. She is glad to sink her individuality in him.”
Finally, consider Paige Patterson, president of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Patterson recently dismissed Hebrew professor Sheri Klouda, simply because she was female. He claims the Bible does not allow women to instruct men. Patterson then launched a new major at the seminary: Homemaking. Only women are allowed to take these courses, which focus on childcare, cooking and sewing -- as well as a woman’s role in marriage. The courses are taught by Patterson’s wife, who is the only surviving female in the school’s 42-person theology faculty.

Considering Patterson’s view of women, we should not be surprised at his response to domestic violence. Participating in a panel on “How Submission Works in Practice,” Patterson tells abused wives to do three things: Pray for their husbands, submit to them, and “elevate” them. He admits that this advice sometimes leads to beatings, but also claims that the men eventually get saved. Apparently, it’s only the men that matter.

Pastors who truly want to help people and save marriages should stop attacking feminism. Instead, teach couples never to hit, choke, kick, threaten or verbally batter their spouse. Preach against domestic violence from your pulpit. Help abuse victims to escape their batterers – permanently. Encourage them to press charges so that justice can be served.

Pastors, if you want to defend marriage, set an example of a loving relationship. Instruct couples to live in a way that makes their spouse want to stay with them. It really does not take a six-tape series to teach the number one tool of a successful marriage: the golden rule.

Frequently asked questions

The most exciting facet of writing a weekly column is receiving reader questions and comments. Each piece goes out to tens of thousands, and then the columnist waits to see who will answer. Some questions tend to be repeated, and thus call for a public response.

Several readers have sent emails asking, “How can you be a Christian and a feminist?” That’s an easy one. A Christian is someone who believes that Jesus, the Son of God, laid down his life for humankind. A feminist is someone who believes that women are human. How can any Christian woman not be a feminist?

Other readers have asked, “Why do you hate George Bush?” The emotion that causes me to point at the Constitution with a look of panic in my eyes in not hatred. It is, in fact, love. Only those who love liberty cry when it is torn asunder in the name of fear. The rest of America shrugs and says, “It was only a Muslim who lost his rights. No one is spying on me or falsely arresting me or my friends, so who cares?” How quickly we forget the lessons of history!

Consider the famous quote by Pastor Martin Niemöller:

In Germany, they came first for the Communists,
And I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a Communist;
And then they came for the trade unionists,
And I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a trade unionist;
And then they came for the Jews,
And I didn’t speak up because I wasn’t a Jew;
And then . . . they came for me . . .
And by that time there was no one left to speak up."

The real question is: When did the public forget the importance of holding our government accountable? Americans have been sold a lie. We have been told that we must agree with the occupation of Iraq, or else we cannot support our troops. Christians in particular are taught that we must only “pray for the President” rather than voicing our dissent. Nobody suggested such a tactic during Bill Clinton’s administration. These days, Bushies call those who disagree with Republican policy traitors or even terrorists. When open dissent is squelched, liberty is only an illusion.

Since last week’s paper was published, a handful of pit bull apologists from around the U.S. have sent a small torrent of emails accusing me of prejudice against their favorite pets. These dog-owners claim we should not judge their pets by their breed, just as we should not judge people by their skin color. My piece took a hard-line approach against all aggressive dogs. If a cocker spaniel or a pit bull bit my child, either dog would meet the same fate. The child would not. Large dog attacks are far more likely to result in death, maiming or disfigurement. Among large dogs, some breeds are more likely to attack than others. For this reason, it makes sense to keep tabs on which breeds have a greater tendency to attack the weak and defenseless. Studies implicate the pit bull as the number one killer dog.

Just since I wrote the piece on killer dogs, several more people have been attacked by pit bulls. A woman in California was attacked by a neighbor’s pit bull in her own garage. The dog wanted the baby boy in her arms. In desperation, she hid the baby in a trash can while she fended off the beast. The pit bull lunged at the trash can and knocked the baby onto the floor. The brave mother threw herself between the pit bull and the baby, so that the vicious animal clamped onto her arms rather than the baby’s head. Nearby construction workers responded to the woman’s screams and beat the dog with their tools until it ran away. They saved the mother’s life, but she still may lose the use of her arms. So much for pit bull lovers’ claims that irresponsible mothers are to blame for attacks on children!

On the first of this month, a six-year-old boy in Dallas was mauled to death by the family pit bull. On Saturday, another six-year-old boy was attacked by another pit bull. His older sister was also scratched and bitten as she tried to rescue him. Elsewhere, mail carriers, police officers and other professionals continue to face danger from aggressive dogs in their line of work. Police officers frequently shoot pit bulls in self defense.

Dogs are not people, and therefore charges of breed prejudice hardly carry the weight of racism or sexism charges. I like dogs, so long as they keep their teeth, claws, barking, and defecating to themselves. I like tigers, too, but I hope none of my neighbors decide to tame a tiger, call it a pet, and tie on a rope in their back yard.

Some readers express great relief at the common sense presented in my column, and want to know “Where have you been all my life?” Before I began the column, some had worried that the local paper was not taking a neutral stance toward politics. The fact is that the paper just did not have an independent weekly columnist who was left-leaning. I am thrilled to be here now, voicing a balancing opinion.

And finally, to all those who begin their letters with “I disagree,” I invite you to continue disagreeing and continue sending your responses via email. I write to address current topics, to expose inconsistencies in our culture, to hold the government accountable, and to facilitate public dialogue. Whether you agree or disagree, I have succeeded in bringing the subject to your attention and presenting a different angle. You are thinking about these issues, and thus the column is a success. Keep reading, keep thinking, and keep responding.

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Animals for the ethical treatment of people

Earlier this summer, a 5-year-old child with Down’s syndrome was reported missing. Hours later her body was found. Authorities charged the girl’s mother with involuntary manslaughter. But wait – this little girl was not killed by her mother. She was mauled to death by the neighbor’s dog.

With Michael Vick’s dog-fighting scandal fresh in the news, animal activists are pushing for laws to protect pit bulls. But what about laws to protect humans – especially children – from vicious animals?

PETA wants people to treat animals better. Where is AETP, Animals for the Ethical Treatment of People? Is there a Lassie or a Benji out there somewhere who will advocate for children? We need such an advocate, because the human public seems more interested in protecting the vicious dogs.

In Paducah a six-year-old boy was mauled by a neighbor’s Alaskan malamute. The boy is recovering. Community response? People fought over the dog, begging authorities not to euthanize it. They said he deserved “a second chance.” A second chance to do what? Make a clean kill next time?

About the same time, a child in Niagara Falls, New York was bitten in the face by a repeat offender. The shepherd mix had bitten another child just two weeks earlier.

The public did respond when Kaitlyn Hassard’s retriever choked her to death with her neck scarf: Over 300 people wanted to adopt the killer dog. If it had been the 6-year-old girl in trouble, how many families would have begged to adopt her? (Hint: Ask social services how many “older” children wait indefinitely on their adoption lists.) Many pet-owners were outraged that the dog was put up for adoption at all, insisting that the girl’s mother was at fault. “She should have never taken her eyes off her that kid for a minute.” Of course, they say the same thing every time a pit bull tears a little child’s face off.

Dozens of news stories each year report on small children disfigured or fatally mauled by such dogs. Invariably, the owner states the behavior was “totally out of character” and the dog was always gentle till now. Does it not occur to these pet owners that “out of character” behavior is very much in character for certain animals?

Pit bulls are not teddy bears, after all. These are large creatures with sharp fangs set in powerful jaws. They are bred to kill. Every fiber of their being is designer-engineered to clamp down on a throat and shake until the victim stops struggling. You can train some of them to act nice most of the time – much as a lion can be tamed – but the killer instinct is there, just beneath the surface, like a trip wire waiting to be triggered.

After the attack comes the tug-of-war between officials who want to destroy the dangerous animal, and the bleeding heart animal lovers who want to “rehabilitate” the animal or (more likely) proclaim its innocence while blaming the mother. If a dog ever harms one of my sweet babies, this will not be an issue. Instead, the two groups can haggle over disposal of the remains.

Ontario banned ownership of pit bulls after a toddler was attacked by three pit bulls that leapt a fence to tear into him. The rescue required half a dozen people and four of them, including both the boy’s parents, required hospitalization. The ban made sense to the province’s attorney general Michael Bryant, who said, “Just as we wouldn’t let a great white shark in a swimming pool, maybe we shouldn’t have these animals on the civilized streets.”

Some counties and one state (Virginia) actually have a vicious dog registry. If officials know where these dangerous animals are, why not destroy them before they can hurt anyone? These animals are desired because of their killer tendencies, not in spite of them. That’s why breeders breed them, that’s why people buy them, and we ought to just admit it.

Absurdly, families increasingly adopt a vicious breed and then domesticate it to play with children. According to a study by Merritt Clifton, editor of Animal People, just three breeds are responsible for 74% of all attacks. Pit bulls top the list, followed by rottweilers, then German shepherds. The Centers for Disease Control says pit bulls kill three times as many people as rottweilers.

In over two-thirds of the cases Clifton studied, the very first known dangerous behavior of the animal proved to be fatal or life-threatening. Dogs bite 4.7 million people annually, and 800,000 dog bites require medical attention. In fact, dogs are the second leading cause of emergency room visits by children.

The majority of offending dogs bite someone at their own home or another familiar place. These dogs aren’t defending the home place, either; 77% are attacking their human family or close friends of the family.

According to the National Canine Research Council, fatal dog attacks are on the rise, having doubled in the last five years. Meanwhile, America seems to have lost all reason when it comes to pets. Dear Abby recently had to advise a reader that, no, it is not okay to shut your 2-year-old alone in a room so the boyfriend’s aggressive dog “Crusher” can roam the house. People have birthday parties for their dogs. They buy RVs so they can take them on vacation, and dress them in Halloween costumes. Some dogs have better health insurance than Georgia’s children.

In local papers, the pet food scandal gets far more press than the proliferation of lead in children’s toys and vinyl lunch boxes. Baby formula recalls are rarely mentioned in the paper, even when deadly bacteria is discovered in cans of fake breast milk. Week after week, we read how China is poisoning our pets. Does anyone care that they are poisoning our children? How easily we shrug off a host of companies committing fraud against children, including corporate giants like toxic-toy Mattel, and the formula-maker Nestle who is responsible for killing a million babies per year. Apparently, they can take our children. Just don’t hurt Fido!

Getting back to Michael Vick, it is interesting to note the extreme responses of the public, the press and even the NFL. Sure, his actions were heinous. But is dog-fighting really a worse crime than assaulting and stalking women? So many professional athletes have been accused of domestic violence that we have long since lost count. Their coaches have been known to bail them out of jail and put them on the field the very next day.

Bobby Chinourd – one of the few athletes actually to be convicted – was sentenced to just one year for terrorizing and threatening to kill his wife. The judge let him serve the sentence in 3-month increments during the off-season, not wanting to limit his time on the field. When Kobe Bryant was accused of raping a woman in a hotel, he received a tremendous outpouring of sympathy and support. Even Rae Curruth, who paid someone to kill his pregnant girlfriend, did not elicit the public outrage aimed at Michael Vick.

When Hawaii quarterback Raphel Cherry was convicted of strangling his wife, head coach June Jones responded, "It just makes you sick for him and his family.” What makes me sick is that athletes who mistreat women garner more sympathy than an athlete who mistreated dogs. Our culture values animals more highly than women and children.

I like dogs. My family still laughs at how I spent one childhood summer living in a cardboard box on the porch because I didn’t want to be away from my mutt Old Yellar. I cried for two days when Old Yellar was struck by a car and died, and I have cried over several dogs since then. I won’t argue with the concept that all dogs go to heaven. I just think some should go sooner than others.

Monday, August 27, 2007

GOP logic: fact or fiction?

Have you heard the latest GOP junk science report? Having exhausted their fury for the termite, industry-backed pseudo-scientists are now laying blame for climate change on the arctic moose. They claim that his belching is responsible for huge amounts of greenhouse gas. He’s such a global terror, they assert, that we need not give another thought to the CO2 put out by factories and power plants.

There are a few problems with this claim. First, the test was based on belching figures calculated from cows, not moose. No one has studied the digestive patterns of moose, because their numbers have dwindled so sharply that there are not many moose left to study. In fact, the number of grazing animals has been declining for quite some time, and quite sharply. Long ago the mammoth became extinct, and then the buffalo population was obliterated with westward expansion. The moose population is down 90%. Yet global warming is accelerating even as these animals disappear. Obviously grazing animals are not the cause of climate change.

The truth is that grazing animals reduce greenhouse gases in a number of ways. First, grazing stimulates more plant growth. Plants remove CO2 from the atmosphere, storing the carbon and releasing the oxygen; therefore, grazing is a good thing for the earth.

Second, grazing animals do not add new carbon to the earth. All greenhouse gasses released by grazing animals came from vegetation, which in turn came from the atmosphere. Even if 100% of the greenhouse components consumed by grazing were released back into the atmosphere, this would be a sum zero game. The same CO2 would simply be cycled round and round, with no net increase of greenhouse gas.

Third, grazing animals store carbon. In reality, the return of CO2 to the atmosphere is not as efficient described above. A portion of the greenhouse components are stored in the animal bones. Some is also trapped in the animal dung.

The dung itself has beneficial effects, too. It acts as a fertilizer, promoting additional plant growth. Another portion of the dung remains in the soil for long periods of time, sequestering some greenhouse components.

As grazing animals disappear from the earth, more plant matter is left to decay. Decaying plant matter releases carbon back into the atmosphere, creating greenhouse gasses. Thus, any creature that consumes currently growing biomass is fighting rather than augmenting global warming.

We must turn away from pointing fingers at the belching arctic moose or even the dastardly termite mound as a way of explaining climate change. Instead, we must look in the mirror. There are only two mechanisms that significantly increase the greenhouse effect: Changes to stored carbon products and changes to the total amount of living plant material.

We add to the greenhouse effect when we burn carbon products that have been previously sequestered. For example, when we burn fossil fuels such as a coal or oil, we are releasing greenhouses gasses that had been sequestered for untold ages. On the flip side, when carbon products are sequestered and stored as in the grazing animal example above, then greenhouse effects are reduced.

Changes to the total amount of living plant material also affect greenhouse gasses. Living plants release oxygen into the atmosphere, which pumps up the ozone layer and offsets greenhouse gas. Deforestation has a tremendous impact, particularly when the trees are burned. Spraying pesticides along the highways and power lines kills plants and then leaves them there to rot. This is a double-whammy, because it takes out carbon-storing, oxygen-producing biomass, and then releases greenhouse gasses as the weeds rot. We can also imagine that this is not good for the insects that eat the grass, the birds and bats that eat the insects, and so on. Some have speculated that highway and power line pesticides may do more harm to the environment than a good-sized coal burning power plant.

To put it even more simply, storing carbon reduces the greenhouse effect, and releasing stored carbon increases the greenhouse effect. In spite of a few belches, the net actions of the arctic moose result in storing carbon, not releasing stored carbon.

Since industrialization, the delicate balance of carbon releasing and carbon storing has been out of kilter. Each year humans create more greenhouse gasses through energy production and industry, while destroying biomass via deforestation and pesticides. We are already paying a price for our actions. Natural catastrophes are occurring in almost biblical frequency and proportions. Scientists tell us this is only the beginning. Earlier this year, 2,000 scientists convened to present the expected trajectory of climate change and its catastrophic effects – including coastal flooding, agricultural failure and stronger hurricanes and tropical storms.

As usual, Republican politicians refuse to let the facts get in their way. Georgia legislators held a hearing just last week titled “Global Warming: Fact or Fiction?” The very name of the conference suggests the sort of head-in-the-sand attitude we’ve come to expect from the Georgia GOP. While the temperatures soared to triple digits outside, Republican legislators calmly assured everyone that global warming was unproven and might never happen.

Global warming is a fact. It is already happening. The ice caps are melting, and at a faster rate than scientists expected. If this is not true, then please explain the tizzy of various countries trying to stake their claim on the oil reserves beneath the melting ice. The only aspect of climate change that is still debated by serious scientists is the cause – human actions, natural cycles, or a combination. To suggest that global warming itself could be “fiction” is pure madness.

Or maybe it is not madness at all. Maybe the denial of reality is deliberate and down-right evil. Reading through the list of so-called climate experts brought in by the Republicans dispels any illusions of a fair hearing. How can institutes designed to support big oil and big coal while opposing environmental laws be trusted to tell our leaders whether climate change is for real? If they wanted the truth about climate change, they would have asked South Georgia farmers, who are suffering one of the worst droughts in history. They also could have asked the Texas flood victims, and the Texas drought and fire victims. They could have asked the sufferers of Hurricane Dean, which was categorized as one of the worst hurricanes ever. They could have asked south Georgians living on the outskirts of the burned-out Okefenokee.

Someday school children will read how Republican politicians denied the obvious and fought all our attempts to save the earth. They will read how science was politicized, and the Republican Party took the side of the coal and oil industry, turning their backs on farmers, wildlife, and the very earth itself. On the other hand, if we let the Republicans have their way, there will be no children left to read the story.

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Catoosa accomplishments: the good, the bad and the funny

Last week the Catoosa County News printed a list of accomplishments cited by Catoosa County Chairman Bill Clark. Some of these accomplishments are indeed good news. A few of the listed accomplishments seem rather dubious, while others reek of hypocrisy.

Positive accomplishments include the sale of three county-owned industrial buildings just outside the landfill on Shope Ridge Road. This is good news because the buildings sat empty for two years, costing taxpayers around $15,000 per month in principle, interest, insurance and utilities. The bad news is that we lost money on the sale. The county constructed the industrial spec buildings for $1.4 million (including land) in 1997, and sold them for $1.2 million in 2007. Although property values have risen during the last decade, the county lost hundreds of thousands of dollars on this venture.

Now that we have finally cut our losses, you would think that Catoosa County government would want to stay out of the speculative construction business. Not so. They are dreaming of constructing a 100,000 square foot industrial building in the hope that someone can be found to occupy it. Even if they choose a better location (and any location is better than the county dump), industrial spec buildings are a terrible risk. Manufacturing facilities often require very specific concrete works and large equipment that cannot be easily retrofitted into an existing building. For this reason, manufacturers prefer to install the concrete and large equipment first, then build the building around it. The only time industrial spec buildings are appealing is when they sit for ten years and then sell for a song.

The first loss may have been an honest mistake. I believe it was Benjamin Franklin who said the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. Isn’t it interesting how an all-Republican board of commissioners whines about funding the Colonnade and the fire departments, yet happily throws a couple of million dollars of taxpayer money into a bad gamble? I thought Republicans were supposed to be fiscally conservative.

Speaking of the dump, another positive accomplishment is the completion of the county’s five-year probation for landfill violations. Most of us had forgotten that our county government is a convicted felon.

Although the landfill is partially closed, hair-brained management ideas continue. The latest misstep (also touted as an accomplishment) is the purchase of adjacent land from a county resident who was complaining of methane migration. Is this really the proper way to deal with pollution, buying out those who might squeal? A better idea is to clean up the environmental problems.

In another real estate accomplishment, Department of Family & Children’s Services moved into the old Ringgold Telephone Company Building. The county spent ridiculous sums renovating the “new” building, while the old (much newer) building sits empty. If DFACS has more space for less money – and if we are not still paying for the vacated building – then this could be an accomplishment. Such answers are not readily available.

Another alleged accomplishment is the $1 charge for riding the Trans-Aid bus. If this is an accomplishment, then why does Chairman Clark feel the need to cite federal and state pressure as a reason for doing it? The charge seems small – almost nominal, really – until you consider who rides that Trans-Aid bus. The bus mainly benefits the elderly and low-income families. People who cannot drive for medical reasons or perhaps cannot afford a car use Trans-Aid to go to work, shop for groceries or attend appointments. This is another example of how we are losing services without a corresponding tax break. Republicans love to slash programs that help the poor and the elderly.

Chairman Clark also touted the opening of the amphitheatre as a county accomplishment. The amphitheatre will certainly benefit the county, but it is difficult to understand why the government imagines they should get credit for it. Looking at the records, it seems the county’s only contribution was the acquisition of prison labor – for which the amphitheatre foundation must reimburse the county. The county will own the amphitheatre, which is on county land at Benton Place, even though the funds to construct and maintain it were raised from the community. I suppose that is some kind of accomplishment, when the county gets something for nothing.

Although Chairman Clark brags about denying new subdivision development, they seem to be sprouting up everywhere. His own ideas for residential growth are bizarre. He claims that narrow, curvy streets and houses closer to the road will make better homes for children. In reality, this plan will result in more accidents involving children and vehicles.

Clark calls for “conservative subdivisions” which have twice as many houses per acre. How is that conservative? Logic suggests that such tactics will result in lower property values, because people will not pay as much for an identical house on a smaller lot. Building lower-value houses is also a recipe for worsening the bedroom community problem, because less property tax is collected on lower-value homes. The cost of putting a child through school remains the same regardless of the size of that child’s yard. The greenspace initially achieved by spacing houses closer together will be swallowed up by new growth in subsequent years – and then there will be twice as many under-funded students.

The sewer grants for Lakeview, on the other hand, are a good start. The sewer interceptor is also positive in that it will allow for commercial and industrial expansion. The trade-off is some loss of local control.

Sewers are only one component of the infrastructure needed to draw businesses into the county. By infrastructure I don’t mean 100,000 square foot spec buildings. Rather, we need to offer build-to-suit sites with full utility services. Companies also consider fire insurance ratings when looking to site a business. Cutting fire service funds (in some cases completely) ensures that commercial growth cannot happen. Neither will we attract businesses by charging exorbitant impact fees for the construction of a factory, or by shutting out all expansion.

It takes hard work to bring in new businesses. Currently we do not even have one paid staff-member at the Economic Development Agency. We have some good people who serve as volunteers in a part-time capacity, during their spare time. That’s all.

Rather than working to attract new businesses, our current leadership works to fend them off, and then brags about it. Included in the Catoosa accomplishments list was a pat-on-the-back for rejecting construction of two asphalt plants. Wait a minute – I thought everyone wanted to correct the residential to commercial ratio. It is often repeated that our tax base is 2:1 residential to commercial, when the ratios should be reversed. How will we ever reach this goal if we turn away industrial growth? Sure, asphalt plants are smelly and yucky. Nobody wants to live next-door to one. But the reality of capitalism is this: Land-owners have the right to develop that land as they choose, within applicable laws and according to the limits of zoning. The commission’s refusal to find a good, safe location for these plants cannot be considered an accomplishment; it is a failure.

There were a few items on the list that made me laugh. “Appointed a committee on open government.” How can a watch-dog committee have any teeth against the official who appointed them? This is worse than the fox guarding the henhouse. It’s more like the fox asking the dog to guard him while he guards the henhouse. It does nothing for the hens.

Repeated episodes of committee-dissolving and buddy-appointing demonstrate that anyone who opposes the chairman will be sacked. We saw this with the abolition of the Planning Commission. The Board of Commissioners reconstructed the Planning Commission with hand-picked members who do not represent every district in the county and can be removed any time at the whim of the commissioners. Only a public uproar has delayed a similar fate for the area fire departments. Clark retaliated against the backlash by cutting fire departments funds. If they won’t go quietly, he will starve them out. Could the “new management of animal control” accomplishment be another example?

In his State of the County Address, Catoosa County Chairman Bill Clark stated that he would give the county a grade of 60. Who then is responsible for the county’s failure?

Jeannie Babb Taylor

Thursday, August 16, 2007

Problems in the bedroom community

Again and again, it comes up: “We’re really just a bedroom community for Chattanooga.” The sentence is spoken in commission, commerce, and planning meetings. It is spoken with a sigh and a sense of sad resignation. Politicians springboard from it, officials vow to battle it, and residents moan about it in the shadow of every tax hike.

A bedroom community is a region characterized by residential rather than commercial growth, so that most people who live there must commute to a nearby metropolis for work. Sometimes this occurs because of an industry shut-down. Along I-75 in north Georgia, it happens the other way around: Chattanooga and Dalton attract employees, who then search for nearby communities where the living is easier. Catoosa County, for example, saw 16 percent population growth from 2000-2006.

Is living in a bedroom community really a problem? And if so, what should be done about it?

Life in a bedroom community has many perks. The focus on suburban life generally leads to better schools, more community involvement, and lower crime rates. For the residents moving to a bedroom community, life is grand.

It is the existing residents who feel the pinch. An overbalance of residential development creates a strain on every public system from sewers to schools. With too few businesses in the tax base, the community relies on residents to foot the bill. Existing residents complain as tax rates continue the inevitable upward trend. They find themselves paying more money for the same services.

Potential new residents weigh these increasing costs before they buy. Existing residents do not have that luxury. They are already established here, and have little choice but to keep paying taxes. They watch as more farmland is converted to housing all around them, resentment building faster than the development itself.

Assuming that being a bedroom community is a problem, what is the solution? The reactionary response is to clamp down on building. Officials saddle builders with impact fees to discourage the construction of new subdivisions. They turn down the developer who appears at a county meeting, plans in hand for a 200-home development. Sometimes they simply place a moratorium on homebuilding, or abolish the zoning and planning board.

These “solutions” only create further problems. A moratorium on homebuilding essentially shuts down the largest industry in a bedroom community. It puts contractors and subcontractors out of work, forcing them to look outside the community for jobs –further skewing the residential overbalance. It also robs lenders, realtors and hardware stores within the community. If the moratorium continues, those businesses move out of the community or shut down altogether. Thus, instead of curing the ills of a bedroom community, the moratorium actually feeds the problem.

A prolonged attack on developers results in falling home values. Growing families will not find newer, larger homes to move into. They will be forced to remain in “starter homes.” Since many middle and upper income families are unwilling to stay in small or outdated homes, they will move to houses in outlying areas. As the homes grow older and wealthier citizens move away, the standard of living in the community falls, the median income falls, property values fall, and the tax base fails. Instead of living in a bedroom community growing too fast for their comfort, residents now find themselves in a slum or a ghost town.

It is time to approach the problem from the other end. If we have two many houses compared to the number of jobs, then we need more jobs, not fewer houses. If our tax base relies too heavily on residential properties, then we need to add business properties, not attack our largest tax revenue source as though it were an enemy.

A slum will not attract the businesses we need. A ghost town will not entice them to site their next location here. Businesses are attracted by healthy, growing communities. Perhaps we will not attract many billion-dollar manufacturing plants. That’s okay. Ninety percent of Georgians are employed by small businesses. The clientele for small businesses already exists right here in this bedroom community. The land is here, ready to be developed into prime business property. The lenders are here, ready to extend funds to anyone with a strong business plan.

All the energy spent battling the “bedroom community” demons should instead be spent leveraging our strengths. We could be launching new businesses and strengthening existing local companies.

One way to support new ventures is through a publicly supported business incubator like the Business Development Center (BDC) in Chattanooga. The BDC houses 53 start-up businesses who benefit from cheap space and shared overhead like office equipment and clerical support. Eighty-seven percent of incubated businesses survive the five-year mark (compared to 20% of businesses founded without incubator support), and 85% remain in the community where they were founded.

In 2004, the Catoosa County Chamber of Commerce commissioned a study to determine if the county was ready for such an incubator. The study group concluded that Catoosa residents were highly entrepreneurial, with over 2,500 microbusinesses (companies with 1 to 4 employees) in the county. However, the study also found that no strong connection existed between Catoosa governments and businesses to foster growth within those Mom-and-Pop shops and make them larger employers tomorrow. The Chamber was advised not to launch the incubator, on the premise that the county was happy being “just a bedroom community.”

Interestingly, the study revealed that the largest sector of microbusiness in Catoosa consists of construction companies. We should be strengthening this sector, not seeking to destroy it with impact fees, moratoriums, and the boast that not a single new subdivision has been approved in the last year. How will we ever grow beyond our status as a bedroom community? Certainly not by blowing up the bedroom.